Cortado vs Macchiato

Drinking coffee, illustration

When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more.

Cortado and macchiato are distinct coffee beverages that reflect the rich coffee cultures of Spain and Italy, respectively. Each has a unique preparation method that involves a careful balance of espresso and milk.

Defining Cortado

A cortado is a Spanish coffee drink that includes an equal ratio of espresso to warm milk to reduce the acidity. The word “cortado” means “cut” in Spanish, reflecting how the milk cuts through the espresso’s strength. To make a cortado:

  1. Prepare a single or double shot of espresso.
  2. Steam a small amount of milk to the point it is warm, but not frothy.
  3. Pour the steamed milk over the espresso.

Defining Macchiato

The macchiato, translating to “stained” or “spotted” in Italian, is typically a stronger beverage in comparison to a cortado. The hallmark of a macchiato is the dash of milk added to the espresso. The steps for a macchiato are:

  1. Extract a shot of rich, full-bodied espresso.
  2. Add a small amount of foamed milk on top of the espresso to mark it, hence the name macchiato.

Both drinks spotlight the espresso, but they diverge in their milk content and the resulting flavor profiles. Cortados offer a smooth experience with reduced bitterness, while macchiatos provide a bolder espresso taste with just a hint of milk.

Espresso as the Foundation

The quality and preparation of the espresso are pivotal in defining the distinct character of both the cortado and the macchiato. Each beverage utilizes espresso in unique ways to deliver a harmonious balance of strength and flavor.

Espresso in Cortado

In a cortado, a single shot of espresso serves as the base, offering a rich and flavorful foundation. The espresso in a cortado is traditionally pulled to be smooth and mellow, complementing the equal part of steamed milk that follows. The espresso’s strength is essential but it’s tempered by the milk, creating a balanced and creamy drink.

  • Espresso-to-milk ratio: 1:1
  • Preparation:
    • Pull a single shot of espresso using an espresso machine.
    • Aim for a concentrated flavor profile without overwhelming bitterness.

Espresso in Macchiato

A macchiato, however, features a double shot of espresso as its core, making it a more potent and highly concentrated drink. The espresso in a macchiato is intense, with ristretto—a shorter pull of espresso that is more concentrated—often preferred. The small dollop of milk foam atop the espresso in a macchiato merely softens the edge, preserving the espresso’s robust character.

  • Espresso-to-milk foam ratio: Typically around 4:1
  • Preparation:
    • Extract a double shot or ristretto using an espresso machine.
    • The double shot is denser, bringing forth a pronounced espresso flavor.

Milk and Its Role

Milk is a defining feature in both cortado and macchiato, primarily affecting texture and taste. It is the delicate balance of steamed milk and foam that distinguishes these beverages from other espresso-based drinks.

Milk in Cortado

In a cortado, an equal part of espresso to warm milk — usually about 1:1 ratio — highlights the espresso while maintaining a creamy texture. They use steamed milk that is lightly frothed to ensure the milk’s richness without a thick layer of foam. This method gives the cortado a smooth and velvety mouthfeel.

Milk in Macchiato

A macchiato, meaning “stained” or “spotted” in Italian, features a small amount of milk. The standard is a shot of espresso with a dollop of milk foam on top. The foam is aerated, creating a light texture that sits on the espresso without integrating completely. This results in a strong coffee flavor with a notable but not overpowering presence of milk.

Note on Alternative Milk Options:

  • Almond Milk: Almond milk creates a slightly nutty flavor and is less creamy compared to whole milk.
  • Oat Milk: Popular for its creamy consistency and it tends to froth well, making it a good alternative for both cortado and macchiato.
  • Coconut Milk: Coconut milk offers a tropical hint but does not froth as well as other milk options due to its lower protein content.

Texture and Flavor Profile

Comparing cortado and macchiato requires an understanding of their distinct texture and flavor profiles, each shaped by the coffee-to-milk ratio and preparation methods.

Cortado’s Texture and Flavor

Cortado is characterized by its balanced taste where the bold flavor of espresso is softened by a roughly equal amount of warm, steamed milk. This results in a creamy texture that mitigates the espresso’s inherent bitterness without overshadowing its rich flavors. The milk’s presence reduces the acidity, leading to a smooth mouthfeel that coffee enthusiasts appreciate for its subtlety.

  • Flavor: Balanced, with reduced bitterness
  • Mouthfeel: Creamy and smooth

Macchiato’s Texture and Flavor

Macchiato, in contrast, offers a more pronounced espresso flavor, with only a dollop of milk foam added on top. The espresso’s bold flavor and bitter taste remain front and center, marked by a higher acidity and less sweetness. The milk foam provides a slightly velvety texture, but the mouthfeel is largely dominated by the strong, concentrated espresso.

  • Flavor: Bold and bitter with a hint of milk
  • Texture: Velvety, with a focus on the espresso’s body

Cultural and Historical Context

The cortado and the macchiato hold significant places within the coffee culture of their respective origins, distinguished by traditional preparation methods that reflect their cultural heritage.

Cortado in Coffee Culture

The cortado, deriving from the Spanish verb “cortar,” meaning to cut, is essentially espresso “cut” with a small amount of warm milk to reduce its acidity. This coffee drink became an integral part of Spanish coffee culture and is known for its balanced flavor and moderate strength. It gained popularity beyond Spain, becoming a staple in countries like Cuba, Gibraltar, and Portugal, where coffee culture appreciates the subtlety of espresso without the overpowering presence of milk. Baristas pay close attention to the ratio of espresso to milk to ensure the authentic aroma and strength are preserved.

  • Origin: Spain
  • Popularity: Spain, Cuba, Gibraltar, Portugal
  • Preparation: Espresso with a small amount of warm milk
  • Coffee Culture: Balance of espresso and milk

Macchiato in Coffee Culture

The macchiato has roots deeply embedded in Italian coffee culture. It is a drink that signifies a strong espresso “stained” or “marked” with a dollop of milk or foam. The intention behind the Italian macchiato is to add a touch of milk to enhance the robust aroma and flavor of the espresso, without significantly altering its strength as in other milk-based coffee drinks. Italian baristas craft this beverage with precision, ensuring the espresso’s bold character shines through, making it a revered option for coffee enthusiasts seeking an authentic Italian coffee experience.

  • Origin: Italy
  • Preparation: Espresso with a dollop of milk or foam
  • Italian Coffee Culture: Strong espresso with a hint of milk

By understanding the precise origins, preparations, and cultural significances of the cortado and macchiato, enthusiasts can better appreciate these coffee drinks’ place within their respective cultures and the broader coffee culture.

Serving Styles and Presentation

The serving styles of cortado and macchiato highlight their unique characteristics through glassware choice and size. Presentation not only adds to the aesthetic but also enhances the tasting experience by complementing the beverage’s flavors.

How Cortado is Served

Cortado is typically served in a Gibraltar glass or a small glass that holds about 4 to 5 ounces, which is the perfect size for this balanced coffee drink. The drink has equal parts espresso and warm, silky milk, which makes it larger than a macchiato but smaller than a latte. A cortado does not usually feature latte art, as the focus is on the harmonious blending of the milk and espresso, resulting in a smooth texture and robust flavors without the interference of syrups or chocolate.

How Macchiato is Served

In contrast, a macchiato is often presented in a demitasse cup, which is notably smaller and highlights the drink’s potency. A traditional macchiato consists of a spot of milk, usually frothed, marked atop a single or double shot of espresso. The milk spot gives the beverage its name—’macchiato’ meaning ‘stained’ or ‘spotted’—and the drink’s appearance is minimalistic with a slight stain of milk. This serving style emphasizes the strong espresso flavor, which can sometimes be accentuated with a dollop of milk froth or a simple design for a touch of elegance.

Variations and Comparisons

Both the cortado and the macchiato offer unique experiences influenced by regional preferences and cultural interpretations of coffee. This section explores how these drinks vary internationally and what distinct characteristics they present.

International Variations of Cortado

A cortado—Spanish for “cut”—is traditionally composed of equal parts espresso and warm milk to reduce the acidity. In Spain, it’s a simple espresso “cut” with a small amount of milk. Venturing into Latin America, variations might include a Cubano, often sweetened with demerara sugar during the espresso pull.

Country Local Variation Notes
Spain Cortado Standard espresso with a splash of milk.
Latin America Cubano Espresso sweetened with demerara sugar and a touch of milk.

International Variations of Macchiato

The term macchiato, Italian for “stained” or “spotted”, reflects the drink’s appearance—espresso marked with a dab of frothed milk. Classic Italian macchiatos focus on the purity of strong espresso with minimal milk. However, international interpretations like the Latte Macchiato and Caramel Macchiato are more commonly found globally. The Latte Macchiato is predominantly steamed milk marked by a shot of espresso, while coffee chains popularized the sweet and layered Caramel Macchiato.

The Macchiato also shares similarities with other coffee beverages:

  • A Cappuccino is roughly one-third espresso, one-third steamed milk, and one-third frothed milk, thus milkier than a traditional macchiato.
  • A Latte contains more milk than a latte macchiato, marked by a smaller ratio of espresso.
  • The Flat White, often confused with the cortado, offers a velvet microfoam mixed with a higher coffee-to-milk ratio.

The table below outlines the differences:

Coffee Drink Espresso Content Milk Content Froth Presence
Cappuccino Moderate High High
Latte Low High Low
Latte Macchiato Low High Moderate
Caramel Macchiato Low High + Caramel Moderate
Flat White High Moderate Moderate

In contrast, an Americano sidesteps milk altogether, diluting espresso with hot water for a milder flavor profile. Each coffee type offers a distinct balance of milk, espresso, and froth, catering to diverse palates and preferences around the globe.

Preparation Techniques

In preparing both a cortado and a macchiato, the espresso machine and milk frother are essential tools. The technique for milk preparation differs significantly between the two, as does the ratio of espresso to milk.

Making a Cortado

To prepare a cortado, an individual needs an espresso machine to pull a standard double shot of espresso into a warm glass or cup. The ideal recipe calls for equal parts of espresso and steamed milk, typically about 1:1 ratio. A frothing pitcher is then used to steam a small amount of milk until it is warm and has a slight, velvety foam—much less than what is used in a latte. The steamed milk is then poured over the espresso to mix well.

  • Equipment Needed:
    • Espresso machine
    • Frothing pitcher
  • Steps:
    1. Pull a double shot of espresso into a glass.
    2. Steam approximately 2 ounces (60 ml) of milk to get a light foam.
    3. Combine the milk with the espresso.

Making a Macchiato

For a macchiato, the process begins with brewing a strong shot of espresso using an espresso machine. Unlike the cortado, a macchiato consists mainly of espresso with only a dollop (a teaspoon or two) of frothed milk on top. The milk is frothed to achieve a thick and rich foam, using less milk than in the cortado. It’s added on top of the espresso shot to mark it, which in Italian, “macchiato” means “stained” or “spotted”.

  • Equipment Needed:
    • Espresso machine
    • Milk frother
  • Steps:
    1. Brew a single or double shot of espresso into an espresso cup.
    2. Froth a small amount of milk until it achieves a thick consistency.
    3. Spoon a dollop of the frothed milk on top of the espresso shot.

Dietary Considerations

When choosing between a cortado and a macchiato, one should consider the caloric content of each beverage as well as the type of milk used, which can affect both calorie count and suitability for different dietary needs.

Calories in Cortado and Macchiato

A cortado typically consists of equal parts espresso and steamed milk, while a macchiato is predominantly espresso with a small amount of milk. Consequently, cortados generally have more calories due to the higher milk content. The average cortado has about 70-100 calories when made with whole milk. In contrast, a traditional macchiato will range between 10-20 calories, given that it contains a mere dollop of milk.

Table of Caloric Content:

Beverage Milk Type (8 oz serving) Calories
Cortado Whole Milk ~70-100
Macchiato Whole Milk ~10-20

Dairy Alternatives

For those who are lactose intolerant, vegan, or simply prefer non-dairy alternatives, several options are available that can also influence the caloric content of these coffee drinks. Almond milk, oat milk, and coconut milk are popular substitutes. Almond milk is the lowest in calories, providing around 30 calories per 8 oz serving. Oat milk is a bit higher, with roughly 60-80 calories per 8 oz serving. Coconut milk is similar to oat milk in terms of calories.

It’s important to note that switching to a dairy alternative can affect the taste and texture of the coffee drink. Additionally, if one opts for sweetened or flavored versions of these alternatives, such as sweetened almond milk or oat milk, the calorie count can increase significantly.

Table of Dairy Alternatives:

Alternative Milk Average Calories per 8 oz
Almond Milk ~30
Oat Milk ~60-80
Coconut Milk ~60-80

When adding sweeteners such as sugar or sweetened condensed milk to either drink, one must keep in mind that this will increase the total caloric intake. Typically, a teaspoon of sugar adds about 16 calories, while a tablespoon of sweetened condensed milk adds approximately 61 calories. These additions should be considered when managing dietary preferences or restrictions.

Caffeine Content and Health Impact

The caffeine content in a cortado and a macchiato can influence their health impacts. Both beverages contain caffeine, a stimulant that can have varying effects on different individuals.

Caffeine in Cortado

A cortado consists of espresso mixed with a roughly equal amount of warm milk, which dilutes the caffeine concentration. A typical cortado contains about 63mg of caffeine per single espresso shot. Due to the milk content, it is also a source of calcium and protein but should be moderated for those managing calorie and fat intake.

  • Caffeine: Approx. 63mg per shot
  • Health Impact: Moderate milk content, source of calcium

Caffeine in Macchiato

Contrastingly, a macchiato, which is espresso “stained” with a dollop of foam milk, offers a higher caffeine ratio due to less milk dilution. A standard macchiato delivers around 63mg of caffeine per shot, mirroring the espresso it is based on, making the caffeine effects more pronounced.

  • Caffeine: Approx. 63mg per shot
  • Health Impact: Minimal milk content, less dilution of caffeine

Caffeine can have health implications such as improved mental alertness and potential increases in metabolic rate. However, sensitivity to caffeine varies, and excessive intake may lead to adverse effects, including disrupted sleep or increased heart rate. Individuals should consume these beverages in moderation and be mindful of their own caffeine tolerance.

Popular Coffee Brands and Variants

Different coffee brands have popularized their signature versions of the Cortado and Macchiato, each offering a unique twist on these classic espresso-based drinks.

Cortado and Macchiato at Starbucks

Starbucks, a global coffeehouse chain, offers the Caramel Macchiato, which stands as a sweet variant of the traditional Macchiato. It layers vanilla-flavored syrup, steamed milk, espresso, and a caramel drizzle, creating a rich and indulgent experience. On the other hand, Starbucks does not offer a traditional Cortado; however, customers can order a similar drink by asking for a doppio espresso with an equal amount of warm milk.

Artisanal and Specialty Cafes

Artisanal and specialty cafes often pride themselves on authentic coffee experiences and thus serve a more traditional Cortado and Macchiato. A Cortado is typically prepared with a balanced ratio of espresso to warm milk to reduce the acidity and enhance the coffee’s creamy texture. A traditional Macchiato, meaning “stained” or “spotted” in Italian, is a strong espresso with just a spot of milk. These versions are starkly different from the sweeter, more elaborate variations found at Starbucks and cater to coffee aficionados seeking simplicity and quality.

Scroll to Top